We bought a small trap today (for squirrels, chipmunks & mice) Within 20 minutes we had our first one, my husband released it a couple miles down the road. Came back, reset and shortly we had our 2nd one. He did not go quite as far the second time...but more than a mile. I saw 3 squirrels crossing the road when I took my 2 mile walk, hope they were mine coming back. My husband said he was going to start spraying paint on their tails (I think he was kidding). When I got home there was one on the feeder. Thanks for posting this topic...it got me to take action.
There is a paint you can get that is designed for this so you don't get in trouble with fish and wildlife. You may even be able to get it from them.
I'm glad the trap is working, sounds like you should of bought two, at the rate you are going one may not last very long.